McDonald’s Refused in Cobham: Local Democracy in Action for a Healthier Future

The recent decision to refuse planning permission for a new McDonald’s restaurant—subject to any appeal—marks an important moment in efforts to promote healthier lifestyles and tackle the obesity crisis placing pressure on the NHS. While not a cure-all, the decision represents a step towards aligning planning policy with public health goals. Elmbridge Lib Dems recognise that some residents and stakeholders may be disappointed, especially those anticipating job creation and increased consumer choice, but the wider context of long-term health and community well-being guided the outcome.

Cobham Lib Dem Councillor, Laurence Wells, played a key role in ensuring that the planning process was transparent, inclusive, and democratic. From the outset, he engaged with local residents through ward surgeries, community meetings and consultations to gather diverse views. Recognising the high level of public interest, Councillor Wells ensured all perspectives—supportive and critical—were fairly represented and submitted for consideration.

In the spirit of enabling full scrutiny, Councillor Wells liaised with planning officers to understand the proposal’s implications on traffic, litter, residents’ amenity and public health. He also met with McDonalds’ representatives to understand the business case, ensuring both sides of the debate were clearly heard. Throughout, Councillor Wells maintained a neutral stance, preserving impartiality for the formal committee decision. By encouraging public participation and scrutinising all aspects of the application, Councillor Wells helped uphold the principles of local democracy.

In committee itself, Councillor Wells was a strong advocate for the public health implications which in the end led to the refusal of planning permission. 

Councillor Wells says, “The decision, if appealed, could prove a significant test case for how national planning policy evolves to address health outcomes. It may influence future rulings and challenge fast food business models based on rapid, nationwide expansion. As such, it stands not only as a local decision but also as a potential milestone in shaping healthier, more community-focused planning frameworks across the country.”

Image credit: Elmbridge Borough Council/McDonalds